Tennessee businesses face a significant risk from severe weather events, particularly hail and tornadoes. These powerful forces of nature can cause substantial damage to commercial properties, leading to costly repairs and potential business interruption. Understanding the intricacies of commercial property insurance coverage and the specific legal landscape in Tennessee is crucial for policyholders when filing a claim for hail or tornado damage. As a public adjuster and claims consultant company serving Tennessee, we at the The David Group aim to empower commercial policyholders with the knowledge necessary to navigate the claims process effectively and secure a fair settlement.
Understanding the Threat: Hail and Tornadoes in Tennessee and Your Insurance
Hailstorms and tornadoes are not uncommon occurrences in Tennessee, where weather patterns can shift rapidly, leading to severe property damage.1 The geographical location of a business within Tennessee can influence the specific risks it faces from these weather events.3 For instance, some areas might experience more frequent or intense hailstorms compared to others. The damage caused by these events can range from minor cosmetic issues, such as dents in roofing or siding, to total destruction of a commercial building.4 Roof damage is among the most frequent and severe consequences of hail storms, but broken windows, skylights, and structural issues are also common.1 This variability in the severity of damage directly impacts the complexity and potential challenges associated with an insurance claim.4
Fortunately, standard commercial property insurance policies generally include coverage for damage caused by hail and tornadoes.1 Many policies utilize a “special causes of loss form,” often referred to as an “all-risk” policy, which covers all direct physical damage unless specifically excluded.7 However, it is important to recognize that the specifics of coverage can vary significantly depending on the individual insurance policy.8 Different commercial property insurance policies, such as basic, broad, and special forms, offer varying levels of protection against hail and tornado damage.7 For example, a basic form policy might only cover named perils, whereas a special form offers broader coverage. Therefore, a thorough review of the “Declarations” page and the “Coverages” section of the commercial property insurance policy is essential to understand the specific limits, deductibles, and covered perils.1 While hail and tornado damage are typically covered, policyholders must be aware of their specific policy details, including coverage limits and any endorsements or exclusions related to wind and hail.1
Key Tennessee Regulations Protecting Commercial Policyholders
Tennessee law includes several regulations designed to protect commercial policyholders during the insurance claims process, particularly concerning prompt claim handling and fair settlement practices.
One crucial aspect is the requirement for insurers to handle claims efficiently. Tennessee law mandates that insurance companies acknowledge and act reasonably promptly upon communications regarding claims arising under insurance policies.11 Specifically, Tenn. Code Ann. § 56-8-105 outlines this obligation.11 Insurers are expected to either affirm or deny coverage for a claim within a reasonable amount of time after the policyholder has filed the necessary proof of loss statements.11 If the insurance company requires additional time to conduct a thorough investigation to determine whether to accept or deny a first-party claim, they must notify the policyholder of this need within sixty (60) days after receiving the proof of loss and any other required information or documents, providing the reasons for the extended timeframe.14 If the investigation remains ongoing after this initial notification, the insurer is obligated to send the policyholder a letter every sixty (60) days thereafter, explaining why more time is still needed.14 These regulations aim to prevent unnecessary delays in the claim process, ensuring that businesses can recover more quickly after experiencing damage.12 Failure by the insurer to adhere to these timelines could potentially be a factor in a bad faith claim if the delay causes additional financial harm to the policyholder.12 While the Tennessee Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act does not provide a private avenue for lawsuits, significant delays in handling a claim could contribute to a broader claim of bad faith against the insurer.
For commercial policies that include replacement cost coverage, Tennessee has a significant regulation known as the “Matching Rule,” outlined in Tenn. Comp. R. & Regs. 0780-01-05-.10(1)(b).15 This rule states that when a loss necessitates the replacement of items, and the replacement items do not match the original items in terms of quality, color, or size, the insurer is required to replace enough of the items to ensure a reasonably uniform appearance. This applies to both interior and exterior losses to the commercial property. This rule can significantly impact the cost of repairs, particularly for older commercial buildings where matching materials may no longer be readily available.17 Without this regulation, insurance companies might only be obligated to pay for the direct replacement of the damaged portion, potentially leaving the property with a noticeable mismatch in appearance and potentially affecting its overall value. For example, if a hailstorm damages several shingles on a roof, and identical matching shingles are no longer manufactured or available due to wear and tear causing color differences, the insurance company, under this rule, would likely need to pay for the replacement of the entire roof to ensure a uniform appearance.17 In such cases, insurance companies or policyholders might utilize an ITEL report from ITEL Laboratories Inc. to determine if a precise match for the damaged materials is possible.17 It is important to note that this matching requirement applies specifically to the replacement of items and does not typically extend to repairs of existing damaged items.19 Commercial policyholders should verify whether their insurance policy includes replacement cost coverage to benefit from this important protection.15 If a policy only provides Actual Cash Value, which factors in depreciation, the application of the matching rule might differ.
Furthermore, Tennessee has enacted the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act (Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 56-8-101 to 56-8-113).12 This legislation outlines various actions by an insurer that are considered unfair claims practices. These include knowingly misrepresenting relevant facts or policy provisions, failing to conduct a reasonable investigation of a claim, offering settlement amounts substantially less than what is ultimately recovered in litigation, and unreasonably delaying the investigation or payment of claims.11 While this act does not create a direct right for policyholders to sue an insurance company for engaging in these unfair practices, it establishes standards of conduct that insurers must adhere to.13 Policyholders who believe their insurer has violated these practices can file a complaint with the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance, which oversees the insurance industry in the state.16 This provides a mechanism for regulatory oversight and potential intervention in situations where unfair claim handling is suspected.
Common Challenges in Commercial Hail and Tornado Insurance Claims
Despite the general coverage for hail and tornado damage, commercial policyholders in Tennessee may encounter various challenges during the insurance claim process.
One common hurdle involves the interpretation of policy language. Commercial insurance policies can be complex legal documents, and ambiguities may arise, particularly concerning the cause of the damage. For instance, there might be disputes about whether damage was caused directly by wind from a tornado (typically covered) or by subsequent water intrusion due to a breach in the building envelope (coverage might depend on the policy wording and whether the initial breach was wind-related).2 It is crucial for policyholders to carefully review their policy to understand any exclusions that might apply. A common exclusion, for example, is flood damage, which often requires a separate flood insurance policy.1 Commercial policies may also contain other exclusions, such as damage resulting from wear and tear, inherent defects, or animal activity.10 Insurance companies might attempt to attribute damage to an excluded peril as a basis for denying or limiting coverage. Therefore, it is essential for policyholders to gather and present strong evidence that clearly supports the covered cause of loss, such as hail or wind from a tornado.29 For example, if a roof leaks after a hailstorm, the insurer might argue the damage was due to pre-existing wear and tear, while the policyholder would need to demonstrate that the hail created openings leading to the water damage.
Disagreements regarding the scope and cost of damage are also frequent challenges. Insurance companies and policyholders may have differing opinions on the extent of the damage caused by the hail or tornado and the reasonable cost to repair or replace the affected property.2 The insurance company will typically send their own adjuster to inspect the property and prepare an estimate of the damages.2 However, policyholders have the right to obtain their own independent repair estimates from qualified contractors.2 Discrepancies between these estimates can lead to disputes. In hail claims, disagreements sometimes arise over whether dents or dings are considered “cosmetic damage” and therefore not covered, even if they might eventually lead to further deterioration.29 Many commercial property insurance policies also include an appraisal clause, which can serve as a method for resolving disputes over the amount of loss.34 It is important to note that in Tennessee, if an insurer acknowledges coverage for a portion of a claim and makes a partial payment, they might be compelled to participate in the appraisal process if a dispute arises regarding the total amount of the loss.34 This provides a potential avenue for policyholders to seek further compensation if they disagree with the insurer’s initial damage assessment.
Finally, understanding business interruption coverage is particularly important for commercial policyholders. Tornadoes and hailstorms can cause significant physical damage that forces a business to temporarily cease operations. Business interruption insurance, often included as part of a commercial property policy or as an endorsement, can provide coverage for the financial losses incurred during this period of downtime.5 This coverage typically includes lost income, operating expenses that continue even while the business is closed (such as rent and utilities), and potentially relocation costs if the business needs to operate from a temporary location.6 However, business interruption claims can be complex and require thorough documentation to demonstrate the actual loss of income and any extra expenses incurred due to the business interruption.5 Insurance companies often scrutinize these claims carefully, so meticulous financial records, including past revenue, projected income, and detailed records of additional expenses, are essential.
Your Rights and Responsibilities After Hail or Tornado Damage in Tennessee
Following hail or tornado damage to a commercial property in Tennessee, policyholders have specific rights and responsibilities they should be aware of to ensure a smooth and successful insurance claim process.
Immediately after the severe weather event, the primary focus should be on safety. Once it is safe to do so, the first responsibility of a commercial policyholder is to notify their insurance company or agent as promptly as possible about the damage. Prompt notification is crucial because insurance policies may contain specific timeframes within which a loss must be reported.1 Delaying notification could potentially jeopardize the claim. Policyholders also have a responsibility to take reasonable steps to prevent further damage to the property by making necessary temporary repairs. This might involve covering broken windows with boards or plastic, tarping damaged roofs to prevent water intrusion, or taking other measures to secure the premises. It is important to retain all receipts for any expenses incurred for these temporary repairs, as these costs may be reimbursable under the insurance policy.
Effective documentation of the losses is another critical responsibility of the policyholder. This involves taking thorough photos and videos of all the damage, both inside and outside the building.1 It is advisable to document the damage from multiple angles and to capture both close-up details and wider views of the affected areas. Creating a detailed inventory of all damaged or destroyed personal property, including equipment, furniture, and inventory, is also essential. Gathering any relevant documents, such as the insurance policy itself, receipts for damaged items, and any previous maintenance records, will further support the claim. Detailed documentation serves as crucial evidence to substantiate the claim and can be instrumental in resolving potential disputes with the insurer. The more comprehensive the documentation, the stronger the policyholder’s position in the claim process.
Policyholders also have the right and responsibility to understand their insurance policy thoroughly. This includes knowing the specific coverage limits for different types of losses, the amount of the deductible that applies, and any exclusions that might be relevant. It is also important to be aware of any deadlines for filing the formal insurance claim. While many policies allow up to a year to file a claim, it is always best to act immediately after the damage occurs. Understanding the difference between Actual Cash Value (ACV) and Replacement Cost Value (RCV) is also critical. ACV policies typically pay the current market value of the damaged property, taking depreciation into account, while RCV policies aim to cover the cost of replacing the damaged property with new materials of like kind and quality. Knowing which valuation method is used in the policy is essential for understanding the expected claim payment, particularly regarding depreciation. RCV policies generally offer more comprehensive coverage for restoring the property to its pre-loss condition.
Working with Your Insurance Company in Tennessee
Navigating the claims process involves significant interaction with the insurance company. Understanding their role and knowing when to seek additional assistance is vital for Tennessee commercial policyholders.
The insurance company will assign an adjuster to the claim. The adjuster’s primary role is to inspect the damaged property, assess the extent of the damage, and determine the amount the insurance company is obligated to pay according to the terms of the policy. Policyholders have the right to be present during the adjuster’s inspection and should ensure that all areas of damage are pointed out and thoroughly reviewed. It is important to be aware that insurance company adjusters in Tennessee are not subject to state licensing requirements. Therefore, policyholders should be mindful that the adjuster represents the insurance company’s interests, and their assessment might not always fully align with the policyholder’s perspective on the loss. This underscores the importance of having independent documentation and potentially seeking your own professional assessments.
In many situations, particularly for complex or substantial commercial claims, hiring a public adjuster like TD Group can be a significant benefit. Public adjusters work exclusively on behalf of the policyholder, not the insurance company. Their expertise lies in interpreting insurance policies, thoroughly documenting the full extent of the damage, preparing and submitting the claim, negotiating with the insurance company, and helping to resolve any disputes that may arise. Unlike insurance company adjusters, public adjusters are required to be licensed in Tennessee. Engaging a public adjuster can level the playing field when dealing with experienced insurance companies and their adjusters, potentially leading to a more comprehensive and fairer settlement for the policyholder. Their in-depth understanding of insurance policies and the claims process can be invaluable in navigating complexities and advocating for the policyholder’s best interests.
There are also circumstances where consulting with a Tennessee insurance attorney is advisable. Legal counsel should be sought if the insurance company denies the claim outright or offers a settlement that significantly underpays the actual losses. Attorneys can also provide assistance in situations where there are disputes over the interpretation of policy language or the extent of the damage. If there is evidence to suggest that the insurance company is acting in bad faith, such as unreasonably delaying the claim process or making deliberately low settlement offers, an attorney can help protect the policyholder’s rights and pursue appropriate legal remedies. Tennessee law imposes an “additional liability” on insurance companies that fail to pay claims promptly and in good faith, and an attorney can help policyholders understand and pursue this potential remedy. Even if the claim appears straightforward, for complex or high-value commercial property claims, it can be beneficial to consult with an insurance attorney early in the process to ensure all legal requirements are met and the policyholder’s interests are fully protected.
Conclusion
Navigating the landscape of commercial insurance claims for hail and tornado damage in Tennessee requires commercial policyholders to be well-informed and proactive. Understanding the potential threats posed by these weather events, knowing the key Tennessee regulations designed to protect policyholders, and being aware of common challenges in the claims process are all essential steps. By taking immediate and appropriate actions after damage occurs, thoroughly documenting all losses, and understanding the nuances of their insurance policy, Tennessee commercial policyholders can significantly improve their chances of a successful claim resolution. When facing complexities, disputes, or potential unfair treatment, engaging the expertise of a licensed public adjuster like The David Group or seeking legal counsel from a Tennessee insurance attorney can provide invaluable support and advocacy. Remember, being informed and prepared is the best way to protect your business and ensure a resilient recovery after severe weather impacts Tennessee.
Works cited
Tennessee Policyholders Bill of Rights – McWherter Scott & Bobbitt, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/2018/12/tennessee-policyholders-bill-of-rights/
Did a Nashville Hail Storm Cause Damage to Your Property? You Need an Insurance Attorney – The Morgan Law Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://policyadvocate.com/blog/did-a-nashville-hail-storm-cause-damage-to-your-property-you-need-an-insurance-attorney/
Tornadoes in Tennessee: Changes in Property Damage Claim Insurance You Need to Understand – Morgan Law Group, P.A., accessed April 12, 2025, https://policyadvocate.com/blog/tornadoes-in-tennessee-changes-in-property-damage-claim-insurance-you-need-to-understand/
Insuring Your Business in Tennessee: What Factors Do I Need to Consider?, accessed April 12, 2025, https://blog.central-insurance.com/business-insurance-tennessee/
Tornado Damage Insurance Claim Lawyers | 3/17/2025, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.forthepeople.com/blog/tornado-damage-insurance-claim-lawyers/
Tennessee Tornado Damage Insurance Dispute Lawyers, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/types-of-claims/tornado-damage/
Business Insights for Tornado Damage Coverage – Insurance Claim Recovery Support, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.insuranceclaimrecoverysupport.com/commercial-insurance-cover-tornado/
Commercial Property Insurance: The Ultimate Guide – LandesBlosch, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.landesblosch.com/blog/commercial-property-insurance-the-ultimate-guide?wtime={seek_to_second_number}
Hail Damage Claims – Morgan Law Group, P.A., accessed April 12, 2025, https://policyadvocate.com/practice-areas/tennessee/property-damage-claims/hail-damage-claims/
Commercial Property Insurance Dispute Lawyer | Wallace Law, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.wallaceinsurancelaw.com/legal-services/commercial-property-insurance-dispute-lawyer/
Tennessee Commercial Property Claims Insurance Lawyers, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/insurance-disputes/commercial-property-claims/
Tennessee – ALFA International, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.alfainternational.com/compendium/insurance-law/tennessee/
Claims Handling Practices – Tennessee | Robins Kaplan LLP Law Firm, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.robinskaplan.com/newsroom/insights/claims-handling-practices-tennessee
Claims Handling Requirements by State – Tennessee, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.propertyinsurancecoveragelaw.com/blog/claims-handling-requirements-by-state-tennessee/
Tenn. Comp. R. & Regs. 0780-01-05-.08 – STANDARDS FOR …, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/tennessee/Tenn-Comp-R-Regs-0780-01-05-.08
Tips for TN Policyholders Impacted by the March 3, 2020 Storm | Tennessee Insurance Litigation Blog | Brandon McWherter & Parks T. Chastain, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tninsurancelitigation.com/2020/03/tips-for-tn-policyholders-impacted-by-the-march-3-2020-storm/
Insurance Consumer Rights in Tennessee (2022) – United Policyholders, accessed April 12, 2025, https://uphelp.org/claim-guidance-publications/insurance-consumer-rights-in-tennessee-2022/
What Does the Tennessee Matching Law Mean to a Roof Insurance Claim?, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.billraganroofing.com/blog/what-does-tennessee-matching-law-mean-roof-insurance-claim
Understanding The Tennessee Matching Law For Roof Insurance Claims, accessed April 12, 2025, https://shinglesmiths.com/understanding-the-tennessee-matching-law-for-roof-insurance-claims/
Tennessee Commissioner of Insurance Confirms: Insurers Have to Pay to Match, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/2017/08/tennessee-commissioner-insurance-confirms-insurers-pay-match/
MATCHING REGS INVOLVING PROP DAMAGE CLAIMS CHART (00214667).DOCX – mwl-law.com, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/MATCHING-REGS-AND-LAWS-AFFECTING-HOMEOWNERS-PROPERTY-CLAIMS-CHART.pdf
“Matching Regulations” Affecting Homeowners’ Insurance Claims – mwl-law.com, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.mwl-law.com/matching-regulations-affecting-homeowners-insurance-claims/
Tornado Insurance Claims | Tennessee | Merlin Law Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.propertyinsurancecoveragelaw.com/blog/tornado-insurance-claim-tennessee/
Commissioner Confirms Insurers Must Pay for Matching | Brandon McWherter & Parks T. Chastain, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tninsurancelitigation.com/2017/08/commissioner-confirms-insurers-must-pay-for-matching/
Tenn. Comp. R. & Regs. 0780-01-05-.10 – STANDARDS FOR PROMPT, FAIR AND EQUITABLE SETTLEMENTS APPLICABLE TO FIRE AND EXTENDED COVERAGE TYPE POLICIES WITH REPLACEMENT COST COVERAGE | State Regulations – Cornell Law School, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/tennessee/Tenn-Comp-R-Regs-0780-01-05-.10
Matching Problem in Property Insurance Claims – IRMI, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.irmi.com/articles/expert-commentary/matching-problem-in-property-insurance-claims
0780-01-05_Unfair_Claims_Practices_Filing.pdf – TN.gov, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tn.gov/content/dam/tn/commerce/documents/insurance/hearingnotice/0780-01-05_Unfair_Claims_Practices_Filing.pdf
Commerce & Insurance (TDCI) – TN.gov, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tn.gov/commerce.html
Understanding Commercial Property Damage Claims: A Comprehensive Guide, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.insuranceclaimrecoverysupport.com/commercial-property-damage-claims/
Tennessee Hail Damage – McWherter Scott & Bobbitt, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/types-of-claims/hail-damage/
Tennessee Storm Damage Insurance Dispute Attorneys, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.msb.law/types-of-claims/storm-damage/
Tornado Insurance Claims: How to File + Common Reasons for Denials – Wallace Law, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.wallaceinsurancelaw.com/tornado-insurance-claims-how-to-file-common-reasons-for-denials/
Post-Disaster Claims Guide – TN.gov, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tn.gov/content/dam/tn/commerce/documents/insurance/posts/TNPostDisasterClaimsGuide.pdf
Commercial Insurance Claims – The Lane Law Firm, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.lanelaw.com/commercial-insurance-claims
Accepting Coverage for Part of a Claim May Subject an Insurer to the Appraisal Process Under Tennessee Law, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.propertyinsurancelawobserver.com/2022/04/11/accepting-coverage-for-part-of-a-claim-may-subject-an-insurer-to-the-appraisal-process-under-tennessee-law/
Understanding the legal aspects of property damage insurance claims and the role of a public adjuster, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.sill.com/latest-news/posts/understanding-the-legal-aspects-of-property-damage-insurance-claims-and-the-role-of-a-public-adjuster/
Get the Best Commercial Property Insurance in Tennessee, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.commercialrealestate.loans/commercial-insurance-guides/tennessee-commercial-property-insurance-guide/
TN Attorney General’s Division of Consumer Affairs Offers Storm Damage Recovery Tips, accessed April 12, 2025, https://www.tn.gov/attorneygeneral/news/2025/4/7/pr25-21.html
FAQs About Property Damage Insurance Claims in Tennessee – United Policyholders, accessed April 12, 2025, https://uphelp.org/claim-guidance-publications/faqs-about-property-damage-insurance-claims-in-tennessee/
The David Group – Claims Consulting & Public Adjusting, accessed April 12, 2025, https://tdgroup.us/
Resources – The David Group, accessed April 12, 2025, https://tdgroup.us/resources/